You are currently not signed in.

Please sign in or register.

论坛 Suggestion Box Ranking System
Votes: +6
Status: Under review

Ranking System

页数: < 1 2
Jul 02, 2012 07:46 am
Sasha User

帖子: 836
入会日期: 16/05/2011

No of followers cannot be the only base to rank systems. It will ruin ranking of new systems with excellent performance. I think No of followers can be a factor with minor share in overall ranking calculation.

I think main factors which will affect ranking should be

Average weekly(or monthly) profit
Average weekly (or monthly) Pips
Drawdown
No of Days
Months ending in profits
Capital of signal provider.

 

What do u think?

Jul 02, 2012 10:57 am
Sebastian User

帖子: 150
入会日期: 29/09/2011

The max. DD. in comparatively to the monthly retun like on Zipsignals is a good

 

For example

A) monthly return 2% and max. DD 1,5%

B) or monthly return 10% and max. DD. 20%

 

Although A is better than B,most would choose B because the high return 

BUT when u use for A the x5 Lot-Size

u have monthly 10% with just 7,5% 

 

Jul 04, 2012 08:15 am

帖子: 939
入会日期: 21/04/2011

Originally posted by Sebastian

The max. DD. in comparatively to the monthly retun like on Zipsignals is a good

 

For example

A) monthly return 2% and max. DD 1,5%

B) or monthly return 10% and max. DD. 20%

 

Although A is better than B,most would choose B because the high return 

BUT when u use for A the x5 Lot-Size

u have monthly 10% with just 7,5% 

 



That is why fxstat will need to carefully weight all factors while making an overall ranking. This weighted ranking can be calculated after maybe poll or some research.

Stick to your rules

Jul 05, 2012 06:23 pm
ironical User

帖子: 734
入会日期: 22/04/2011

Originally posted by Sasha

No of followers cannot be the only base to rank systems. It will ruin ranking of new systems with excellent performance. I think No of followers can be a factor with minor share in overall ranking calculation.

I think main factors which will affect ranking should be

Average weekly(or monthly) profit
Average weekly (or monthly) Pips
Drawdown
No of Days
Months ending in profits
Capital of signal provider.

 

What do u think?



Another important factor will be trading style. 

The good or ill of a man lies within his own will. – Epictetus

页数: < 1 2