You are currently not signed in.

Please sign in or register.

Stoch EA

გვერდი: 1
Jun 26, 2013 09:03 am
Champ User

გვერდები: 711
გაწევრიანდა: 17/05/2011

Very nice EA with impressive backtest results. But it is not tested by me. I have found it somewhere in past with backtest image. 

You can retest it.

Test it on eur/usd with 30 minute timeframe to get best results.


Stoch EA.mq4

Jun 28, 2013 04:15 am
ironical User

გვერდები: 734
გაწევრიანდა: 22/04/2011

Nice results. Thx for sharing.

Back test show impressive results. I will test it once again to reconfirm it.

The good or ill of a man lies within his own will. – Epictetus

Jun 29, 2013 04:18 pm
Sasha User

გვერდები: 836
გაწევრიანდა: 16/05/2011

How did u get those results on 30 minutes timeframe?

Here are the results for eur/usd on 30 minute timeframe.


Jun 30, 2013 03:19 pm
Jogi User

გვერდები: 685
გაწევრიანდა: 06/06/2011


Huge difference. Sasha have u tested it on other timeframes?

Jul 01, 2013 05:34 am
illiterate User

გვერდები: 561
გაწევრიანდა: 21/04/2011

 Wow. it means original owner has shown false image or maybe he has given incorrect information about timeframe and pair. 

This system doesnt look profitable in anyway on 30 mint timeframe as shown by sasha.

Jul 02, 2013 05:14 am
Champ User

გვერდები: 711
გაწევრიანდა: 17/05/2011

You r right. Tests by sasha are not in any way similar to image posted by me. I dont know if the original owner posted back test image of another EA with this one.

I will also test it once with different pairs and timeframes to see if it gives any better results.

Jul 28, 2013 06:32 pm

გვერდები: 939
გაწევრიანდა: 21/04/2011

I have seen that some developers, just to gain some popularity, post false backtest results and images which is what happened in this case. The original owner of this EA has copied image of some other back test and pasted with this.

Stick to your rules

Oct 02, 2013 05:48 pm
illiterate User

გვერდები: 561
გაწევრიანდა: 21/04/2011

Yes it is highly possible as backtest results by sasha do not match with the results posted with EA. Another possibility is change in settings of this EA. Maybe Owner of this EA tested it with multiple settings and posted the best results.

გვერდი: 1